2023 Ford F-150 XL
Verdict #910 · 45,270 miles · VIN 1FTEW1EP4PFA98358 · Stock # MOOSED
“A $35,997 2023 Ford F-150 XL with 45,270 miles — priced over the market.”
Pros
- 2023 Ford F-150 XL — mainstream parts and broad owner support keep running costs sane
- Ben Davis Ford Inc carries a 5-star store (DealerRater 4.6 from ~590 reviews) in our research
- Strong nameplate for its segment; well-supported by independent shops
Cons
- Priced over the mileage-matched market (39.4k-mi comp $33,230 (below KBB); 42.6k-mi comp $32,500; 62k-mi comp $30,978)
- 45,270 miles — budget for wear items and get a pre-purchase inspection
- No history report pulled — verify accidents, service, and title before signing
Analysis
At $35,997 with 45,270 miles, this 2023 Ford F-150 XL sits above our market read. Comparable data: 39.4k-mi comp $33,230 (below KBB); 42.6k-mi comp $32,500; 62k-mi comp $30,978. ~$2.8k-$3.5k over the near-twin comps. Pass at this price. Ben Davis Ford Inc is a 5-star store (DealerRater 4.6 from ~590 reviews), which is a point in the seller’s favor, but the price is what decides a verdict — and this one is too high for the miles and trim. We have not pulled a history report for this verdict — verify accidents, service records, and title status yourself. At this price we would pass or negotiate — the number needs to come down before this becomes a buy.
Market Comparison
Market reference: 39.4k-mi comp $33,230 (below KBB); 42.6k-mi comp $32,500; 62k-mi comp $30,978. This listing at $35,997 (45,270 miles) is rated MOOSED.
Dealer: Ben Davis Ford Inc, Auburn IN. History report not pulled for this verdict — verify accidents, service, and title before signing.
The Original Listing
A live snapshot of the dealer’s listing page, captured automatically.
