“Four thousand six hundred over KBB Fair Purchase, with certified comps cheaper AND lower-mileage.”

Analysis

The 2021 Colorado Work Truck is a fine honest truck — 2.5L four, 6-speed auto, CornerStep bumper, ready to work. But at $24,455 with 69,482 miles, the math doesn’t work: KBB Fair Purchase Price is $19,820, so this tag is nearly $4,600 over fair. And the comps destroy it — a certified great-value 2021 WT moved at $22,995 ($1,455 under CARFAX value) and a 41,568-mile certified unit lists at $23,626, both cheaper AND lower-mileage than this one. The truck itself looks fine, but the price is the whole problem. MOOSED until the number comes down to the high-teens/low-$20s where KBB says it belongs.

Market Comparison

Dealer reputation: Kelley Chevrolet — 4.6/5 on DealerRater across 1,705 reviews.

2021 Chevrolet Colorado Work Truck market (Oct 2026): KBB Fair Purchase Price $19,820; certified great-value 2021 WT moved at $22,995; 41.6k-mi certified unit at $23,626; 64.3k-mi 1-owner at $24,770. At $24,455 with 69,482 miles, this unit is ~$4,600 over KBB fair.