2024 Toyota Sienna XLE 7-Passenger FWD
Verdict #267 · 23,936 miles · VIN 5TDYRKEC5RS190850 · Stock # MOOSED
“Low miles, but $44,665 overshoots Edmunds clean retail by ~$4,600 — the premium isn’t justified.”
Pros
- Only 23,936 miles — genuinely low for a 2024
- XLE: SofTex, moonroof, power liftgate — the family sweet spot
- Sienna hybrid: 35/36 MPG, bullish resale, legendary durability
- Franchise dealer: Fort Wayne Toyota, 4.2/5 across 1,156 reviews
Cons
- $44,665 is ~$4,600 over Edmunds clean dealer retail ($40,069); even mileage-adjusted it’s ~$2k high
- No CARFAX badge on this unit’s photo — history unverified at a premium price
- FWD in Indiana — AWD Siennas command the resale premium here
- At this price you’re in 2024 Limited territory with more miles
Analysis
The 2024 Sienna XLE is the right van — and 23,936 miles is genuinely low. But the price asks you to pay for those miles twice. Edmunds puts clean dealer retail at $40,069 (at average 42.5k miles); even crediting a full mileage adjustment for the 18k fewer miles, fair value lands around $42,000–$43,000. This Fort Wayne Toyota unit asks $44,665 — roughly two thousand over fair, with no CARFAX badge on the photo to sweeten the history story, and it’s front-wheel drive in a market where AWD Siennas hold the premium. Low-mile 2024 XLEs do list up to $48,250 (AWD), so the ask isn’t fantasy — it’s just not a deal. The van will sell; it just shouldn’t sell to you at this price. At $42,500 with a clean report, this becomes interesting.
Market Comparison
Dealer reputation: Fort Wayne Toyota — 4.2/5 on DealerRater across 1,156 reviews.
2024 Sienna XLE market: Edmunds clean dealer retail $40,069 (42.5k avg miles); low-mile comps (18.7k mi AWD) list to $48,250. Mileage-adjusted fair value for 23,936 miles: ~$42,000–$43,000. At $44,665, this unit asks ~$2,000 over fair — the low-mile premium is overcharged.
The Original Listing
A live snapshot of the dealer’s listing page, captured automatically.
