“About $6,000 over what every comparable 2013 V6 coupe sells for.”

Analysis

The 2013 Mustang V6 coupe is the honest Mustang: the 3.7-liter V6 with 305 hp, 6-speed automatic, Race Red over black, stripe package, and alloys. Clean and straight in Premier’s lot photos.

The price is not honest: $17,399 with 126,066 miles. Comparable 2013 Mustang V6 coupes at similar miles sell at $10,889 (131,695 mi), $10,888, $11,595, and $12,668 — and a 126,928-mile example sold at a Hagerty auction for $11,000. Premier’s number is roughly $6,000 over the market. Mustangs hold value well, but they don’t hold $6,000 of fresh air. This is the most overpriced car I’ve seen in the whole stress test. Moosed, hard.

Market Comparison

Market check: Comparable 2013 Mustang V6 coupes: $10,889 (131,695 mi), $10,888, $11,595, $12,668; a 126,928-mile example sold at auction for $11,000. At $17,399 with 126,066 miles, this car is about $6,000 over the market — the clearest Moosed of the batch.