2012 Buick LaCrosse Premium 1
Verdict #899 · 171,339 miles · VIN 1G4GD5ER7CF230915 · Stock # BUY
“A $2,500 2012 Buick LaCrosse Premium 1 with 171,339 miles — priced right at the market.”
Pros
- Priced at or under the mileage-matched market (171k-mi twin comp $6,288 (great price); JD Power avg price paid $7,950; trade-in avg $2,50…)
- 2012 Buick LaCrosse Premium 1 — mainstream parts and broad owner support keep running costs sane
- Ben Davis Chevrolet carries a 4-star store (DealerRater 4.6 from ~1,600 reviews) in our research
Cons
- 171,339 miles — budget for wear items and get a pre-purchase inspection
- No history report pulled — verify accidents, service, and title before signing
- Priced at trade-in value — less than half the 171k-mile twin comp. 171k miles is the risk; the price is a gift.
Analysis
At $2,500 with 171,339 miles, this 2012 Buick LaCrosse Premium 1 sits at or under our market read. Comparable data: 171k-mi twin comp $6,288 (great price); JD Power avg price paid $7,950; trade-in avg $2,500. Priced at trade-in value — less than half the 171k-mile twin comp. 171k miles is the risk; the price is a gift. Ben Davis Chevrolet is a 4-star store (DealerRater 4.6 from ~1,600 reviews), which is a point in the seller’s favor, but the price is what decides a verdict — and this one is right in the fair zone. We have not pulled a history report for this verdict — verify accidents, service records, and title status yourself. If the history comes back clean, this is a fair buy at the asking price.
Market Comparison
Market reference: 171k-mi twin comp $6,288 (great price); JD Power avg price paid $7,950; trade-in avg $2,500. This listing at $2,500 (171,339 miles) is rated BUY.
Dealer: Ben Davis Chevrolet, Auburn IN. History report not pulled for this verdict — verify accidents, service, and title before signing.
The Original Listing
A live snapshot of the dealer’s listing page, captured automatically.

