2016 Jeep Renegade Sport
Verdict #789 · 174,390 miles · VIN ZACCJBAT1GPD35920 · Stock #AP-1903 MOOSED
“2016 Renegade at $9,093 — CARFAX lists the same car at $8,395.”
Pros
- Renegade: Jeep character in a city-friendly size
Cons
- Same VIN on CARFAX at $8,395 all-in — this ask is $700 over
- 174,390 miles — the highest mileage in the entire block
- CARFAX notes minor damage on top of the miles
Analysis
This one is simple: the same VIN appears on a CARFAX listing at $8,395 all-in with minor damage noted, while this ask is $9,093. You’re being asked to pay $700 more than the car’s own listing history supports — for a 174,390-mile Renegade, the highest mileage in the entire P9 block, with minor damage on the record.
The Renegade’s 2.4L Tigershark has oil-consumption issues that get worse with miles, and 174k is deep into that territory. Even at $8,395 it would be a caution; at $9,093 it’s MOOSED. The CARFAX listing is the comp that kills it.
Market Comparison
2016 Jeep Renegade Sports with 165–180k miles list nationally at $7,000–$9,000. At $9,093 with 174,390 miles this car is priced at the top of the band — while a same-VIN CARFAX listing shows $8,395 all-in with minor damage, $700 under this ask.
The Original Listing
A live snapshot of the dealer’s listing page, captured automatically.
