2025 Tesla Model Y Performance
Verdict #463 · 18,144 miles · VIN 7SAYGDEF1SA371269 · Stock #N/A MOOSED
“Nearly-new Performance, but $3k+ over comparable listings.”
Pros
- 2025 Model Y Performance with only 18,144 miles – nearly new
- Performance trim: 0-60 in 3.5 seconds, track-capable dual-motor AWD
- Tesla Supercharger network and software ecosystem
Cons
- $44,097 is $3,000-$6,000 over comparable 2025 Model Y Performance listings ($37,359-$40,885)
- EV depreciation is real – overpaying up front is never recovered
- Insurance costs on the Performance trim run high
Analysis
A nearly-new 2025 Model Y Performance with 18,144 miles is an appealing EV, but the price is not. At $44,097 it sits $3,000-$6,000 above comparable 2025 Performance listings, which trade between $37,359 and $40,885 at similar or slightly higher mileage. A CarGurus-listed Performance with 17,000 miles at $40,885 is the direct comp, and it is $3,200 cheaper.
Model Y depreciation is well documented, and the Performance trim depreciates harder than the Long Range. Buying above market on a fast-depreciating EV is the worst combination in car buying. This is a MOOSED on price: find a market-correct Performance in the high $30s to low $40s.
Market Comparison
Comparable 2025 Tesla Model Y Performance listings at ~17k-33k miles: $37,359-$40,885. This vehicle at $44,097 with 18,144 miles is priced above the market band.
The Original Listing
A live snapshot of the dealer’s listing page, captured automatically.
