2025 Cadillac CT5 Premium Luxury
Verdict #477 · 3,664 miles · VIN 1G6DS5RK6S0113891 · Stock #N/A MOOSED
“Costs more than a new one at KBB fair price. Absurd.”
Pros
- 2025 CT5 Premium Luxury with only 3,664 miles – essentially new
- Full factory warranty intact
- Premium Luxury trim with the big display and leather
Cons
- $45,985 is above the KBB Fair Purchase Price for a NEW 2025 CT5 Premium Luxury ($44,800)
- A comparable 2,525-mile used example lists at $42,000 – $4,000 cheaper
- Paying more than new-car fair price for a used car makes no sense
Analysis
This is a pricing logic failure. A 2025 Cadillac CT5 Premium Luxury with 3,664 miles at $45,985 costs MORE than the KBB Fair Purchase Price for a brand-new 2025 Premium Luxury ($44,800). You would pay a premium over new-car money for a car someone else has already driven 3,664 miles.
The direct used comp makes it worse: a 2,525-mile 2025 Premium Luxury lists at $42,000, a full $4,000 cheaper with fewer miles. The vehicle is essentially new and the warranty is intact, but none of that justifies paying over new-car fair price. MOOSED on price – buy the new one or the cheaper used comp.
Market Comparison
KBB Fair Purchase Price for a NEW 2025 Cadillac CT5 Premium Luxury: $44,800. Comparable used listing at 2,525 miles: $42,000. This vehicle at $45,985 with 3,664 miles is priced above new-car fair price.
The Original Listing
A live snapshot of the dealer’s listing page, captured automatically.
