2015 MINI Countryman Cooper S ALL4
Verdict #134 · 111,672 miles · VIN Not listed · Stock #Not listed MOOSED
“A $9,731 MINI priced over book while cheaper same-mileage comps sit on the market.”
Pros
- ALL4 all-wheel drive and turbo punch — the fun spec
- Green over black is a sharp, desirable color combo
- Franchise dealer with a 4.6-star iSeeCars rating
Cons
- $9,731 vs Edmunds clean dealer retail of $9,274 — priced over book
- A 115,396-mile comp listed at $7,985 — $1,746 less
- No VIN or history shown on a 111k-mile turbo MINI
Analysis
The Countryman S ALL4 is the right spec, but the number is wrong. Edmunds clean dealer retail for a 2015 S ALL4 is $9,274; Tom Kelley asks $9,731 — nearly $500 over book before any negotiation. Worse, the open market has cheaper equivalents: a 115,396-mile example at $7,985 is $1,746 less money for 4,000 more miles.
High-mileage MINIs live or die on maintenance history, and this listing shows no VIN, no records, no accident data. Overpaying up front on a car that demands a clean bill of health is backwards.
Verdict: MOOSED. Cute car, wrong price — the $7,985 comp is the one to chase.
Market Comparison
- Edmunds clean dealer retail, 2015 Countryman S ALL4 — $9,274
- 2015 Countryman S ALL4, 113,085 mi — $10,695 (carsforsale)
- 2015 Countryman S ALL4, 115,396 mi — $7,985 (carsforsale)
- 2015 Countryman S ALL4, 111,273 mi — $10,799 (Edmunds)
The Original Listing
A live snapshot of the dealer’s listing page, captured automatically.
